KEY POINTS
-
The Federal High Court in Abuja has affirmed Yahaya Bello as the APC candidate for Kogi Central Senatorial District in the 2027 elections.
-
The court dismissed Momoh Yusuf Obaro’s challenge, ruling that he failed to exhaust the party’s internal dispute resolution procedures.
-
Justice Inyang Ekwo also rejected Obaro’s unsigned documents claiming victory in the party primary, describing them as having dubious origins.
The Federal High Court in Abuja has upheld the emergence of former Kogi State Governor, Yahaya Bello, as the All Progressives Congress (APC) candidate for Kogi Central Senatorial District in the 2027 general election.
Justice Inyang Ekwo delivered the judgment on Thursday, November 19, dismissing a suit filed by Momoh Yusuf Obaro, who challenged Bello’s emergence as the winner of the party’s senatorial primary conducted on May 18, 2026.
Obaro had asked the court to declare him the authentic winner of the primary election, but the judge ruled that his case lacked merit.
Plaintiff failed to exhaust party’s internal procedures
Justice Ekwo held that Obaro failed to exhaust the APC’s internal dispute resolution mechanisms before approaching the court.
The judge noted that although Obaro had submitted a petition to the party’s Appeal Committee, there was no evidence that he subsequently appealed to the National Working Committee (NWC), as required by the party’s constitution.
Citing Paragraph 15(3) of the APC Constitution, the judge said aggrieved party members were required to seek redress through both the Appeal Committee and the NWC before instituting legal proceedings.
Justice Ekwo ruled that Obaro’s decision to approach the court without completing the prescribed internal processes amounted to a breach of a mandatory condition for filing the suit.
He consequently resolved the issue in favour of the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) and Bello, who were listed as the first and second defendants respectively.
Court rejects documents claiming primary victory
The judge also faulted documents presented by Obaro to support his claim that he won the APC senatorial primary.
Justice Ekwo observed that the documents were not signed by the chairman or secretary of the electoral committee responsible for conducting the exercise.
He ruled that the unsigned documents lacked probative value and described them as being of dubious origin.
The judge further advised Obaro, who was not a lawyer, to consult his legal counsel before presenting the documents to the court, noting that he had been misled by whoever supplied them.
Justice Ekwo also pointed out that Obaro had undertaken, through his party membership and nomination documents, to abide by the APC’s internal dispute resolution procedures and refrain from instituting court proceedings before exhausting those channels.
The court held that he was bound by that undertaking.
Bello’s lawyer welcomes judgment
Following the dismissal of the suit, Bello’s counsel, Paul Daudu, SAN, described the judgment as sound and well-reasoned.
Daudu said the ruling upheld the rule of law and the democratic process, adding that Bello’s emergence as the party’s candidate reflected an overwhelming endorsement by party members.
He argued that the plaintiff had sought judicial intervention to obtain a victory he failed to secure during the party’s primary election.
The court dismissed the suit and ordered the parties to bear their respective costs.